"Saltburn": A Cinematic Exploration of Vibes Amidst a Divided Audience

Emerald Fennell's sophomore feature film, "Saltburn," has sparked a fascinating divide among audiences and critics alike, prompting an exploration of the intricate relationship between vibes and substance in contemporary cinema. As a professional editor with an eye for clarity and concision, I delve into the multifaceted layers of "Saltburn" to dissect its visual provocations, narrative intentions, and the overarching debate surrounding its reception.

Set against the backdrop of the 00s, "Saltburn" navigates the tumultuous world of a middle-class interloper embedded within a vacuously affluent family. The film's reception can be encapsulated within two distinct camps: those who dismiss it as a flashy, self-indulgent medley of empty provocations and those who embrace its remix of familiar narratives, seeing it as an absorbing erotic thriller with titillating shocks.

Visually, "Saltburn" undeniably excels, boasting lush and attractive cinematography, complemented by the presence of the Euphoria actor and screen heartthrob, Jacob Elordi. However, the crux of the debate lies in the interpretation of its squirm-inducing visuals – from a character slurping bathwater to a provocatively bold ending. Are these elements indicative of perverse genius or mere illusions, cheap tricks masquerading as substance?

The film's division, I argue, is not merely a result of its satirical intentions but rather stems from its reliance on vibes – an abstract, ineffable force that permeates the narrative. Vibes, often dismissed as a woo-woo counter-culture term, serve as a powerful tool in cinema, offering a gateway to the intangible aspects of different times, places, and eras.

Fennell, adept at crafting vibes, leans heavily on luscious montages, nostalgic needle drops (most notably MGMT's "Time to Pretend"), and dioramas of tortured beauty and brawn. The film deliberately prioritizes an immersive experience, urging audiences to look and feel first, think second. However, the question that lingers is whether these vibes enchant or distract, whether they enhance the narrative or overcompensate for its thin characters and groundless plot.

Drawing parallels to contemporary TV's "Euphoria," "Saltburn" raises questions about the prioritization of vibes over substance. Both works are rich in color, excessively provocative, and frustratingly thin, leading to a divided audience response – is it genius or empty, genuinely titillating or baiting, edgy or dumb?

In my evaluation, both "Saltburn" and "Euphoria" falter in overestimating their power, mistaking vibes for depth. "Saltburn's" aim for mid-2000s nostalgia appears haphazard, lacking specificity in character behaviors and cultural references. Fennell's provocative elements, while uncomfortable, often feel disconnected from a genuine exploration of human character, resulting in shock without authentic surprise – an abundance of vibes without a narrative anchor.

In conclusion, "Saltburn" stands as a fascinating case study in contemporary cinema, where the allure of vibes collides with the need for substantive storytelling. While undeniably visually captivating and provocative, the film's divisive reception highlights the ongoing discourse on the role of vibes in shaping audience perceptions and expectations.

As regards my opinion, I consider it a masterpiece; 

   A masterpiece often connects on an emotional level, and if "Saltburn" resonates with you emotionally, it suggests the film has successfully tapped into a deep and personal response. Whether through its characters' struggles, the exploration of desire, or the provocative themes, the emotional impact can elevate it to the status of a masterpiece.

   If the film's visuals captivate you and leave a lasting impression, it speaks to the power of its aesthetic brilliance. The deliberate use of cinematography, montages, and nostalgic needle drops might create a visual feast that enhances your overall viewing experience.

   A masterpiece often weaves a complex and compelling narrative. If you find "Saltburn" to be intellectually stimulating, with its innovative storytelling and unexpected plot twists, it suggests a level of narrative sophistication that contributes to its masterpiece status in your eyes.

   Your appreciation for the characters, their depth, and the performances may contribute to considering "Saltburn" a masterpiece. If you find the portrayals to be nuanced, with characters that resonate and leave a lasting impact, it adds to the film's overall artistic merit.

   A masterpiece often has a timeless quality, but it can also be relevant to the contemporary audience. If "Saltburn" addresses societal issues or cultural dynamics in a way that feels pertinent and thought-provoking to you, it adds a layer of significance that enhances its standing as a masterpiece.

   If the film exhibits cinematic innovation, whether through its use of vibes, thematic exploration, or the way it challenges traditional norms, it can contribute to the perception of it being a groundbreaking and masterful piece of cinema.

   Ultimately, if you derive immense enjoyment from "Saltburn," appreciating its unique qualities, provocative themes, and narrative choices, it becomes a personal masterpiece. The joy and satisfaction you derive from the film are crucial components in designating it as such.