David Gilmour’s Luck and Strange: Why This Album Makes Everything Else Sound Pathetic
Let’s be honest. Most rock legends of his generation have either retired gracefully into boring lives, gone completely mad, or started collaborating with people who make reality TV look like Shakespeare. But Gilmour? No. He’s done what only he can do. Sat quietly for nine years, said absolutely nothing, and then sauntered back with an album so effortlessly brilliant it makes every modern pop star look like they’re smashing toy instruments together in a sandbox.
From the very first track, you know it’s him. That honey-dripped guitar tone slides in like a warm knife through nostalgia. It’s not a guitar. It’s a living, breathing creature with a doctorate in emotional torment. It sighs. It moans. Occasionally, it explodes. And you just sit there thinking, yes, this is what proper music sounds like.
I don’t care if you’re tone-deaf. I don’t care if you normally think Pink Floyd is a brand of floor polish. When Gilmour plays, you feel it in places you didn’t even know existed. The man could play the theme tune to the weather forecast and you’d end up crying into your beer, and probably spilling it down the front of your jumper, because life has a sense of humour like that.
The title track, Luck and Strange, is a slow drive through your own memories. Reflective, slightly sad, and completely beautiful. It’s the musical equivalent of standing at the end of a pier at sunset with a glass of whisky in hand, thinking about all the catastrophes you’ve survived, and realising you’d probably do them all again because, well, what else are you going to do?
And that’s the charm of this album. It doesn’t scream. It doesn’t compete. It doesn’t feel the need to impress anyone with fireworks or synth nonsense. It’s calm, elegant, and full of musical maturity — the kind only a man who’s spent half a century perfecting the art of ignoring trends could achieve.
Polly Samson’s lyrics are sprinkled on top like the finest Maldon salt. Words that actually mean something. No “baby, shake it” nonsense. No “yeah, yeah, let’s go.” This is proper poetry. The kind that reminds you humans used to have feelings before we replaced them with emojis and TikTok dances.
The production is immaculate. Warm, rich, and deep, like being wrapped in a blanket woven from old valve amps while a choir of angels tunes the bass. There’s space. There’s air. You can hear the instruments breathing. Which is more than you can say for most of today’s pop, which sounds like it was recorded inside a microwave with a hangover.
Some critics might whine it’s slow. Too reflective. Not enough Floyd. To them, I say, shut up. This isn’t an album for people who want instant gratification. This is for grown-ups who can sit down, close their eyes, and let their brain melt a little — preferably with a large whisky and zero distractions.
Because here’s the thing: David Gilmour doesn’t just play music. He paints with sound. Landscapes appear. You’re in the cosmos one second, by the sea the next, staring at the sky and wondering why everything suddenly feels right. Every solo, every chord, every little nuance has been carefully considered, measured, and matured. There’s restraint here that most modern musicians couldn’t comprehend even if you threatened them with a double shot of reality.
Listening to Luck and Strange, you realise genius doesn’t age. It evolves. It matures. It gains character, like whisky, Aston Martins, or that smug satisfaction you get when everyone else is wrong and you’re still sitting there thinking, I bloody told you so.
And yet, in a world where everything is fast, fake, and filtered, Gilmour’s music still takes its time. Thank God for that. Because when he finally plays, when that Stratocaster sings, it’s not just music. It’s proof that the universe still knows how to listen. It’s proof that there are still artists out there willing to make something timeless rather than something disposable. It’s proof that, sometimes, old dogs not only learn new tricks, they teach everyone else how to play catch properly.
So if you’ve been ignoring the work of the great David Gilmour, do yourself a favour. Open a bottle of whisky, sit down, and let Luck and Strange do what it does best: remind you that music can still break your heart, soothe it, and make you feel alive all at once. Sit down, and let a man who’s been perfecting guitar tones since before you were born remind you what real music sounds like.
Because at the end of the day, while the world shouts, hypes, and clatters, Gilmour whispers. And somehow, his whisper is still the loudest sound in the room.
Comments